Skip to content

Spoil 'Em with a Wag Bag!

Shop our New Arrivals

Free Shipping on all orders over $40.00!

Dog
- Dry Food
- Wet Food
- Freeze Dried
- Biscuits & Treats
- Bones & Chews
- Toys
- Health Products
- Accessories
- For Adult Dogs
- For Puppies
- Shop by Health Condition
Cat
Small Pet
Bird
Learn More
Log In
View My Subscription

Dog
Cat
Small Pet
Bird
Learn More
Log In
View My Subscription

Home / Shop / Cat Toys

Cat Toys

Filter and sort 84 products

Availability

In stock

Price

The highest price is $20.99

$

—

$

Product type

Cat Grooming Tools (3)
Cat Toys Balls (7)
Cat Toys Catnip (5)
Cat Toys Interactive (25)
Cat Toys Plush (39)
Cat Toys Teaser (4)
Cat Treats Crunchy (1)

Sort by

Clear

Availability

In stock

Price

The highest price is $20.99

$

—

$

Product type

Cat Grooming Tools (3)
Cat Toys Balls (7)
Cat Toys Catnip (5)
Cat Toys Interactive (25)
Cat Toys Plush (39)
Cat Toys Teaser (4)
Cat Treats Crunchy (1)

Filter and sort

84 products

$2.99 / KONG Nibbies Cat Treats Whitefish 1ea/2 oz
Sold out

$11.99 / KONG Connects Angler Door Fish Cat Teaser 1ea/One Size
Sold out

$13.99 / Kong Cat Teaser UFO
$6.99 / Kong Cat Naturals Teaser Fish
$6.99 / KONG BatABout Flicker Mouse Cat Toy 1ea/One Size
$3.99 / KONG Wubba Mouse Catnip Toy Assorted 1ea/One Size
Sold out

$5.99 / KONG Wubba Caticorn Cat Toy Pink/Light Blue 1ea/One Size
$8.99 / KONG Wrangler Angler Fish Cat Toy Assorted 1ea/One Size
$4.99 / KONG Window Teaser Catnip Toy Assorted 1ea/One Size
$4.99 / KONG Tropics Bird Cat Toy Assorted, 1ea/One Size
~~$5.49~~ $5.99 / Kong Teaser Butterfly Cat Toy Assorted, 1ea/One Size
$7.99 / KONG Softies Buzzy Llama Catnip Toy Beige 1ea/One Size

Previous page 1 2 3 … 7 Next page

Contact Us

Nature's Select Midwest

22272 N Pepper Rd Unit A, Lake Barrington, IL 60010

Call: (847) 852-1700

Email: orders@nschicago.com

Text: (847) 852-1700*

*By texting us, you agree to receive messages from Nature’s Select. Reply HELP for help. Reply STOP to stop receiving messages from us. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. View our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service for more information.

Shop Products
- Pet Food
  - Dry Food
  - Canned Food
Biscuits and Treats
Bones and Chews
Health Products
Toys
Accessories
Cat Essentials

Ingredients
Privacy Policy
Shipping Policy
Refund Policy
Terms of Service

Subscribe to our newsletter

Subscription description

Email

© 2025 Nature's Select Midwest, All rights reserved. Powered by Shopify

Search

Trending Now

From $9.95 / Wholesome Rewards Original Chicken Biscuits
5.0
From $13.95 / Wholesome Rewards Gourmet
5.0
$19.95 / Wholesomes Jerky Strips Grain Free - 25 oz.
5.0

{hulk.reorder.detail:} {hulk.reorder.list:}